Space management has changed a lot over the years. Planning software keeps getting better, and we have more data than ever: store-level sales, loyalty and shopper data, and now online order data too. And yet so many of the same problems are still with us. Sound familiar?
- For retailers: high out-of-stocks, more items on the shelf without more sales, trouble balancing inventory, assortment and presentation, listing decisions driven by fees, and stores treated alike based on section size rather than shopper behavior.
- For suppliers: planograms used to squeeze in as many items as possible without regard to the retailer's strategy, a growing pile of tactical planogram requests, and planogramming seen as an administrative cost.
Now add a new twist: in many stores, the shelf is also the warehouse for online orders. Pickers are shopping the same aisles as your customers, often at the same peak times. That makes strategic space management more important than ever. Done well, it goes far beyond a picture of the shelf. It drives inventory, labor, online order accuracy and, ultimately, the retailer's bottom line.
The 5 best practices
1. Build planograms on performance data, not just dimensions
Add item-level performance data to your planograms so products are judged on how they sell, not just how big they are. Good sources include syndicated data from NielsenIQ or Circana, retailer POS and loyalty data, shipment data and, now, online order data. Shopper research adds a deeper layer, showing why shoppers choose what they do. With performance data at the right level, you can build planograms for store clusters or even individual stores.
2. Plan with forecasts, not just history
History is the easiest data to use, but last year won't necessarily repeat itself. Use a forecast for the period the planogram will actually run. A good forecast accounts for seasonality, price changes and promotions, and many of today's forecasting tools use AI to pick up patterns faster. Just remember to sanity-check the output!
3. Merchandise for the shopper, and the picker
Put the items shoppers are most likely to buy where they're easiest to see and reach. Use the consumer decision tree to lay out the section the way shoppers actually shop it. And use common sense: tall items at the top, heavy and glass items down low.
Today there's a second shopper in the aisle: the online picker. Logical adjacencies, consistent item locations and accurate shelf labels help pickers move quickly and cut down on substitutions. Shopper focus also leads toward store-cluster and store-specific planograms. Move in stages: one planogram, then a few, then localized, then store-specific.
4. Confirm the objective before you build
In my P&G days, we produced hundreds of planogram versions for new launches and concepts, often with little lead time, a lot of labor, little analysis of the impact on inventory and sales, and weak execution in store. Sound familiar? My advice: agree on the concept with a simple shelf picture first, then build full planograms once it's accepted.
Good reasons to build a planogram include:
- New product launches, including private brand launches
- New concepts, such as a new consumer decision tree, a new category or a new merchandising approach
- Meeting the needs of many: smaller retailers and categories often get a generic planogram. Automating planograms to fit each retailer's assortment makes them far more relevant.
5. Plan for the store as a fulfillment hub
When the store shelf also fills online orders, every space decision affects in-store sales, online order accuracy, inventory and labor at the same time.
- Count online demand when you set shelf capacity and restocking, not just in-store sales.
- Fit the case pack: aim for shelf capacity that holds at least one full case, plus enough for peak demand, so stock goes straight to the shelf instead of the backroom.
- Decide where orders should be filled: the store shelf, the backroom, a dark store or a micro-fulfillment center. High online volume may be better picked away from the shelf.
- Use the endless aisle: long-tail items can live online only, freeing space for what shoppers buy most in store.
- Check compliance: use store audits or shelf-scanning technology to confirm the planogram is actually in place.
A word about AI and automated planograms
AI is changing space planning fast. Today's tools can generate store-specific planograms in minutes, optimize facings against sales and inventory targets, and flag compliance issues from shelf images. That's exciting, and it can free your team from a lot of manual work!
But here's my caution: automation without the strategic thinking up front just gets you more planograms, faster. Not necessarily better ones. A tool will optimize whatever you feed it. If no one has defined the category's role, the target shopper, the consumer decision tree, the assortment strategy and the balance between in-store and online demand, you can end up with thousands of planograms that each look fine on their own but don't add up to a strategy.
The upfront work still matters most:
- Be clear on the strategy: the category role, the target shopper and what the shelf needs to achieve
- Get the inputs right: clean product data, good forecasts and the right performance measures
- Set the rules: decision trees, adjacencies, case pack minimums and online pick demand
- Review the output: check that the planograms balance the shopper, the picker, inventory and profit before they go to stores
Let AI do the heavy lifting, and let your people do the thinking. That's where the real value is.
Questions to ask your organization
- Do we have clear assortment and space strategies for each category and channel?
- When do we think about assortment and space in the new product launch process?
- Do we have gold standards for product data, processes, category reviews and planograms?
- Do our planograms account for online pick demand?
- If we use AI or automated planogramming, who sets the strategy and rules, and who reviews the output?
- Is space management training available to everyone who affects the shelf, from new product launches and item changes to logistics and eCommerce? We're not talking planogram development, but understanding the shelf!
Wrap-up
Put these practices to work and you'll see the difference: more efficient planogram teams, shelves that balance the shopper, the picker and the income statement, and better execution in store. That's space that works harder!
Free download: Space That Works Harder. See how shelf decisions flow through to inventory, labor and profit, with formulas, worked examples and a checklist for planning the omnichannel shelf.
Want to build these skills across your team? CMKG offers training on assortment and space management, and we can customize programs for you, your team or organization. Explore our training or contact me directly.
Happy learning!
Sue

