Category Management Insights for Retail and CPG Teams for Retail & CPG teams.

Private Brand Pricing — What Does the Price Gap Tell You?

Written by Sue Nicholls, Founder & President CMKG | Jan 27, 2016, 3:57:14 PM

Your private brand is priced below the leading national brand. That supports its value position.  Then the national brand goes on promotion.

What happens to the gap? What happens to shopper choices? And what happens to total category sales and gross profit?

These are useful questions for pricing, buying, private brand, category and supplier teams. Understanding the relationship between prices helps you evaluate whether the offer on the shelf supports what the retailer is trying to achieve.

Let’s look at where to start.

Start with the role of each private brand

If your retailer has several private brands, how do you analyze them? Grouping everything into one “private label” total can hide differences between an opening-price range, a core brand and a premium or specialist offer. Each may serve different shopper needs and compete with different products.

Before comparing prices, clarify:

  • Who is the brand intended for?
  • What does it promise shoppers?
  • Which products do shoppers consider alongside it?
  • What role should it play in the category?

A premium private brand needs a price position that reflects its intended quality, benefits and differentiation. An opening-price range needs to deliver against a different promise. Your analysis should help you understand whether each brand is delivering its intended role.

Compare products on a meaningful basis

Pack prices are easy to compare. Different pack sizes can make the comparison misleading.

  • Use an equivalent measure, such as price per 100 grams, per litre, per wash or per serving, where appropriate.

  • Then consider whether the products are comparable in the ways that matter to shoppers. Ingredients, performance, convenience, dietary suitability and packaging can all influence the choice.

  • Also distinguish regular prices from promotional, loyalty and multibuy offers. Record which channel, location and period the comparison covers.

Otherwise, you could end up comparing one brand’s regular price with another’s member-only offer and drawing conclusions that don’t reflect the choice available to everyone.

Look at how the gap changes

Here’s a simple illustrative example using equivalent products and pack sizes.

Price comparison Regular week National brand promotion
National brand price $5.00 $3.50
Private brand price $4.00 $4.00
Private brand price position $1.00 below $0.50 above

 

The private brand’s price stayed the same, but its position changed considerably. Does that matter to shoppers in this category?

  • Look at what happened to units, sales, gross profit and the mix between brands.

  • Then consider the other activity during the period. Were both products available? Did the national brand receive a display, advertising or additional digital visibility?

A change in sales during a promotional week gives you something to investigate. Several factors may have contributed.

Connect price with perceived value

Price tells you what shoppers pay. Understanding value requires knowing what they believe they’re getting. You might see a clear quality difference between two products. Do shoppers see it too? Research can help you understand which attributes matter, how people perceive the brands and what alternatives they consider.

For example, two brands with similar perceived benefits may compete closely when their prices change. A more differentiated product may attract shoppers for reasons that extend beyond price.

Use that understanding to evaluate the gap. The retailer’s intended positioning and the shopper’s perception need to connect.

Evaluate the total commercial result

Before changing the price, consider the wider consequences. A lower private brand price might increase units while reducing gross profit per unit. A national brand promotion might attract shoppers, shift existing purchases between brands or bring purchases forward from later weeks.

Ask what the activity contributes to the category and the retailer’s objectives. Where data allows, examine:

  • Changes in total category units, sales and gross profit.
  • Switching between products and brands.
  • Trial and repeat purchasing.
  • Availability and inventory requirements.
  • Performance after the promotion ends.

Use comparable periods and account for seasonality, distribution and other activity when interpreting the results.

Agree how teams will act on the findings

Pricing analysis becomes more useful when teams understand what to do with it.

  • Private brand teams can clarify positioning.

  • Pricing teams can evaluate gaps and offers.

  • Buyers and category teams can assess the product mix and economics.

  • Supply chain and operations can plan for changes in demand.

  • Suppliers can contribute research and analysis that explains how their products fit into the retailer’s offer.

Together, teams can establish practical pricing guidelines, including which products to compare, how to handle promotional exceptions and when to review the results.

There is no single price gap that suits every private brand, category and retailer. Start with the shopper, test your assumptions and evaluate the outcome.

Choose one private brand product and follow its price gap over time. Does the offer shoppers actually see support the position you intended?

Want to build these skills across your team? Explore our training or contact me directly.

Happy learning!

Sue